Opinion: Columbia County Commissioners Duncan and Carraway Belittled a Constituent Instead of Answering Him
Opinion by Anonymous
Watch the meeting starting at 8:40 — Columbia County Board of Commissioners, Oct 6, 2026 (relevant portion 8:40–21:17)
The relevant portion of the October 6, 2026 Columbia County Board of Commissioners meeting begins at 8:40 and ends at 21:17.
Watch the meeting starting at 8:40
In my view, Chairman Doug Duncan and Commissioner Michael Carraway crossed the line between responding to criticism and belittling the constituent delivering it. After the speaker criticized the Board, both Duncan and Carraway directed criticism back at him.
A constituent's support for one commissioner does not make his criticism of the Board improper. Nor does it require him to continue supporting the Board indefinitely. Residents are entitled to reassess their representatives, applaud decisions they support, and challenge conduct they oppose.
Duncan and Carraway were wrong to make the speaker himself the target. If they disagreed with his claims, they could have identified the disputed facts and answered them in private. Criticizing a resident for being critical serves no useful public purpose.
The chairman has an additional responsibility: setting the tone and maintaining decorum. That responsibility demands restraint when criticism is directed at him or the Board personally. In my judgment, Duncan's approach was thin-skinned, and Carraway's response reinforced that impression. Their positions give them authority to conduct county business—not a license to belittle the people they represent.
Robert's Rules of Order draws a clear distinction between forceful disagreement and personal attack. Sections 43:20–43:21 direct members to address the merits of the pending question, avoid personalities, and refrain from attacking another member's motives. Strong criticism of a measure is permitted; personal attacks are not. (muni.org)
Those provisions specifically concern debate among assembly members. Whether they formally govern this Board's interactions with public speakers depends on the Board's adopted procedures. Nevertheless, they establish a useful standard: address the substance of the criticism rather than diminish the person raising it.
Belittling a speaker is never an acceptable substitute for answering a concern. Officials can enforce reasonable speaking limits and maintain order without turning public comment into a confrontation. A resident should not have to flatter the Board to receive respectful treatment.
This exchange also takes place against a backdrop of distrust over data-center development. Questions about undisclosed end users, LLC structures, and nondisclosure agreements deserve direct answers. When constituents believe important information has been concealed, defensive treatment at a public meeting only makes matters worse.
The Board cannot expect residents to accept its assurances while leaving fundamental questions unresolved. Explain who benefits. Explain the agreements. Identify the basis for withholding information. Provide the records that support your claims.
Chairman Duncan and Commissioner Carraway: do your jobs, grow up, and develop thicker skin. You hold public office, and you are open to criticism.
In my view, the undisclosed data-center end users, the appearance of hiding behind LLCs, and the NDAs you signed have earned this Board its constituents' distrust. That distrust was not created by a resident stepping up to the microphone. Point of Order, Mr, Duncan and Carraway. Look it up. It’s only Parliamentary Procedure. Or do the rules only apply to me, not to thee?
This Board brought that shame upon itself. It is the Board's responsibility to repair it.
Sources & Credits
Video: Columbia County Board of Commissioners meeting, Oct 6, 2026 (YouTube, relevant portion 8:40–21:17).
Reference: Robert's Rules of Order — Decorum During Debate (§§ 43:20–43:21), Municipality of Anchorage.
// DID THIS RESONATE?
CLICK TO SHOW YOUR SUPPORT
ORIGINAL SOURCE
Columbia County Board of Commissioners / YouTube