It costs $100/month to keep this site running — any contribution is appreciated.DONATE via Venmo @NoMoreDataCenters· Please share our links with like-minded people.

A $6B Data Center Developer Told Festus, MO Not to Worry About Their Water — Then Shrugged
BACK TO ARCHIVE
CRITICALWATER USAGE

A $6B Data Center Developer Told Festus, MO Not to Worry About Their Water — Then Shrugged

No More Data CentersOctober 15, 2026⌖ Festus, Missouri (Jefferson County) — Glenkee Court subdivision
SHARE

Asked who holds him accountable on water safety, the developer of a $6 billion data center sitting on top of his neighbors' aquifer answered: "To my children."
Pressed on whether he'd drink a glass of the facility's treated discharge water, he added: "It's possible." This is the man selling Festus, Missouri the cloud.

In Festus, Missouri, the developer behind a proposed $6 billion hyperscale data center sat in front of a community terrified about its water and offered the kind of answers that make a room go cold. The clip — widely shared on Facebook — captures Bob Clark, founder of St. Louis-based Clayco and a principal in developer CRG, fielding the one question that actually matters: what happens to the neighbors' wells?

His reply, on the record: "That is a question I cannot answer. That is an engineering question, but I will get you an answer." Asked who holds him accountable on water safety, he said "To my children." Asked whether he would drink a glass of the facility's treated discharge water to prove it's safe: "It's possible."

It is the industry's favorite move — deflect, sentimentalize, and never give the number. Let's look at what is actually at stake under Festus.

The aquifer beneath the homes

The Infrastructure Development Agreement between CRG and the city of Festus gives CRG the right to drill private wells if the municipal water supply can't meet the facility's demand. Any new wells drilled for the site would draw from the same aquifer that sits beneath the homes in the adjacent subdivision — including Glenkee Court, where four residents are now suing.

More than 300 Festus residents filed formal complaints under city code requesting independent environmental studies, including hydrogeological assessments of that aquifer. According to the lawsuit, the city has not responded to a single one. And no independent hydrogeological study of the aquifer beneath the data center site has ever been conducted. CRG has not announced plans to commission one.

The Oregon warning Clark waved off

The Festus dispute didn't happen in a vacuum. Days before Clark's news conference, Amazon Data Services agreed to pay $20.5 million to settle a class-action lawsuit — Pearson v. Port of Morrow — brought by residents of Morrow County, Oregon, who alleged the company's data centers worsened nitrate contamination of the Lower Umatilla Basin aquifer. Federal court records documented discharge nitrate levels reaching eight times Oregon's legal safety limit. That aquifer is the sole drinking water source for up to 45,000 people on private wells.

It was the first time a tech company paid damages tied to the public health impacts of data center operations. Clark's answer to the parallel risk in Festus was a shrug and "It's possible" — not a study, not a guarantee, not a meter.

How the deal went down

CRG first contacted Festus officials on Aug. 4, 2025. By Aug. 8, the city administrator was describing discussions as "CONFIDENTIAL." The council annexed five parcels 8-0 in November 2025 and rezoned seven parcels from residential to industrial 6-2 on Nov. 27. The 29-page Infrastructure Development Agreement was released on a Friday, March 27, for a vote the following Monday, March 30 — passing 6-2 over a packed, jeering gymnasium at Festus High School, where the mayor cut off public comment after two hours.

A lawsuit filed April 8 in St. Louis County Circuit Court charges the city and CRG with 12 counts, including unlawful spot zoning, Missouri Sunshine Law violations, civil conspiracy, and due process violations. Text messages entered as exhibits show officials allegedly briefing council members in groups of three to stay under the quorum threshold, and one official describing data center opponents as a "sideshow of uneducated people."

Then the voters spoke. In the April election, Festus residents removed four of the eight council members who approved the project — replacing them with data center opponents. Clark's response: he doesn't think they speak for the whole town, and the project is "still on" because "our rights are vested."

The "golf course" dodge lives here too

The dismissive water deflection in the clip is part of a playbook. Across the industry, the favorite trick is to wave off water concerns by pointing elsewhere — "golf courses use more," "it's a closed loop," "it's just employee drinking water." A developer-sponsored webinar claimed the Festus facility's daily water needs would be limited to potable, employee use, with the main water concern being fire suppression.

Here is what that talking point deliberately leaves out:

  • Location matters. A closed loop in a wet county is not the same as wells punching into a rural Missouri aquifer that a whole subdivision drinks from. Water is local. National averages are a smokescreen.
  • It evaporates. Data center cooling water is largely evaporated away, which concentrates pollutants like PFAS, nitrates, and heavy metals into whatever the facility discharges back. The Missouri Coalition for the Environment flags this directly.
  • Scale and growth. A single large data center can consume over 5 million gallons of water per day, and these facilities multiply. One $6 billion campus is rarely the last.
  • "Someone else does it too" is not a defense. Two things can be a problem. Pointing at a golf course to excuse a data center on top of someone's well is what a snarky idiot says when they don't have a real answer.

Missouri barely regulates water quantity

Part of why the deflection lands softly in rooms like Festus's is that Missouri barely regulates water amount at all. Per the Missouri Department of Natural Resources, the state is a riparian-rights state with no restrictions on the amount of water that can be used, provided the use is "reasonable" and stays in-state. The only threshold is a reporting requirement for "major water users" withdrawing 100,000+ gallons per day.

In other words: a data center can pull enormous volumes and the state's role is mostly to ask it to file an annual report. When the man at the front of the room says "it's not that bad," he is leaning on a regulatory vacuum, not a guarantee.

The real answer they won't give

If the water use were truly trivial, the developer wouldn't need sentimentality and shrugs — he'd need a meter and an independent study. Instead, Festus got "To my children" and "It's possible," while 300 formal requests for a hydrogeological assessment go unanswered. The cloud is not weightless, and the water it drinks is not free. When the person whose job is to sell you the facility reaches for a deflection instead of a number, it's because the honest answer doesn't help them.


Sources & Credits

Clip: Community video — Festus data center developer responds on water, Festus, MO (Facebook).
Primary: "Residents push back as developer promotes benefits of $6 billion Festus data center," KSDK 5 On Your Side (Bob Clark's water answers; aquifer under Glenkee Court; 300+ complaints; Oregon Amazon settlement).
Council vote: "Festus council approves $6 billion data center plan despite massive public pushback," St. Louis Public Radio (March 31, 2026; 6-2 vote, 360 acres north of Hwy 67).
Recall: "Missouri town fires half its city council over data center deal," POLITICO (April 13, 2026).
Context: Missouri Coalition for the Environment — Data Centers (5M+ gal/day; evaporative concentration of PFAS, nitrates, heavy metals).
Regulation: Missouri DNR — Data Centers / Water Use (no restriction on water quantity; major-user reporting at 100,000+ gal/day).

// DID THIS RESONATE?

CLICK TO SHOW YOUR SUPPORT

DIALOGUE CHAMBER

(1 voice)
ESTIMATED ENERGY COST: 0.0000 kWh
No More Data CentersOct 15, 2026 · 17:51

What a snarky idiot. You're sitting on top of your neighbors' aquifer and your answer to water safety is 'To my children' and 'It's possible'? That's not reassurance, that's a deflection from someone who doesn't have the real number. 300 residents asked for a hydrogeological study and you gave them a shrug. Show us the meter or sit down.

NO MORE.DATA CENTERS

Exposing the physical weight of the digital cloud. Every byte has a cost. Every server has a footprint.

THE CLOUD IS NOT INVISIBLE

DATA HAS WEIGHT